Industry Analysis Report

Rental Agency • Brookhaven New York

Generated on May 09, 2026

Total Businesses

24 analyzed in detail

Categories

32 different business types

Services

397 unique service offerings

Top Service

20.8% Property management

Avg Rating

4.5 ★ average

Total Reviews

1,347 across all businesses
Top 10 Most Common Services
#1
Property management
5 businesses (20.8%)
#2
Property maintenance
4 businesses (16.7%)
#3
Rent collection
4 businesses (16.7%)
#4
Home management
4 businesses (16.7%)
#5
Rental property management
4 businesses (16.7%)
#6
Administrative management of property
3 businesses (12.5%)
#7
Condo complex management
3 businesses (12.5%)
#8
Repairs & maintenance
3 businesses (12.5%)
#9
Property investment management
3 businesses (12.5%)
#10
Vacation property management
3 businesses (12.5%)
Industry Insights & Competitive Analysis
Quick Snap Report
Get Quick Snap $27

For just $27, get a quick analysis comparing your Google Business Profile services with your website to see if they're aligned correctly. Perfect for testing before investing in larger reports. Usually delivered within a few hours, but always less than 24 hours in your email.

Website Guru Report
Get Website Guru Report

If you want to know what your competitors are doing with their website only, this will give you all of what your competitors are doing with their websites and provide a solution that you can add to your website to build up the things you are missing very quickly without rebuilding your website or paying a monthly cost for SEO.

LPRAudit.com Report
Get LPR Audit Report

Get 60 local competitors and 50 national ones, compiling all the best of the best and giving you a blueprint and tools to fix your listing and website.

Highlight: This is to fix both your Google Profile and your Website, the most robust solution.

Why This Data is Important for Your Business

This comprehensive analysis of 24 businesses reveals critical competitive intelligence for the rental agency industry in Brookhaven New York. With 397 unique services identified across the market, businesses are likely missing significant service opportunities. Google's AI algorithms and customers actively scan business profiles comparing service descriptions, categories, and completeness. Businesses that strategically expand their service descriptions and fill market gaps will dominate local search results and customer acquisition.

We're showing you the top 10 most common services your competitors are using. With 397 total unique services discovered across all competitors, how many is your company missing? Did you know that each time your Google profile loads, Google and AI systems can see your categories, services, and descriptions? This is why making sure you put in the most important services with properly written descriptions is crucial to make your Google profile better than your competition.

This is the basics—not anything special—but as you can see, almost all of the companies on this list are in need of help fixing this problem. We have three options that can help:

It's your choice—we know that this quick industry report has opened your eyes to the problem. Get one of the reports and fix the problem.

How to Read This Report

The Business Comparison Table below shows your competitors and their Google Business Profile optimization levels. Use the service checkmarks to see which competitors offer similar services to you, and pay attention to the "% Descriptions" column—businesses with higher percentages are more likely to rank better in Google searches.

Key Competitive Analysis Points:

  • Compare your total number of services vs the highest competitor - the gap shows missed opportunities
  • Identify which services your top competitors are targeting that you might be missing
  • Look for patterns in service offerings across successful competitors
  • Focus on services with checkmarks across multiple high-performing businesses
Business Comparison Table
Company Name Website Open GBP Reviews Rating # Categories # Services % Descriptions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 3mi Competitors 5mi Competitors
Keyrenter Eastern Long Island Property Management Open Website Open GBP 58 5 ★ 2 6 100.0% 1 5
All Island Property Options Open Website Open GBP 39 4.7 ★ 1 19 0.0% 0 0
Buy and Rent New York Realty Open Website Open GBP 142 5 ★ 1 8 0.0% 0 0
Touchstone Property Management, LLC Open Website Open GBP 31 4.4 ★ 6 39 0.0% 4 6
New York Rental By Owner Open Website Open GBP 39 4.8 ★ 5 74 2.7% 0 0
Heatherwood Lakeside Village Open Website Open GBP 176 4.6 ★ 3 20 25.0% 4 5
Olander & Sons Rental Management Open Website Open GBP 12 5 ★ 2 8 0.0% 0 0
FIRE PLACE REALTY, INC. Open Website Open GBP 3 3.7 ★ 1 17 0.0% 4 5
Real Property Management Unlimited Open Website Open GBP 21 4.8 ★ 1 18 0.0% 0 0
H&G Realty - NY, Inc. Open Website Open GBP 5 4.2 ★ 3 0 0% 0 5
Rosemont Brookhaven Open Website Open GBP 439 4.1 ★ 2 14 100.0% 4 6
Stay Exclusive Properties Open Website Open GBP 5 4.2 ★ 2 6 0.0% 4 6
⛵️RentABoat.com ⛵️ New York Open Website Open GBP 3 3.3 ★ 3 10 0.0% 3 5
Heatherwood Luxury Rentals Open Website Open GBP 11 3.1 ★ 1 3 0.0% 0 0
Essential Property Management Open Website Open GBP 23 4.7 ★ 1 42 4.8% 0 0
Long Island Finest Party Rentals Open Website Open GBP 67 5 ★ 4 10 0.0% 2 5
North Woods Maine Cabins Open Website Open GBP 35 5 ★ 5 59 0.0% 0 0
Gemstone events & Decoration party rentals long island new york Open Website Open GBP 32 5 ★ 4 41 0.0% 2 5
Heatherwood Pinewood Village Open Website Open GBP 57 4.3 ★ 3 18 38.9% 1 4
Debi Sudaley - The Agency Open Website Open GBP 1 5 ★ 2 5 0.0% 1 7
Brookhaven Apartments Open Website Open GBP 21 4 ★ 3 1 0.0% 0 0
Stonegate At Middle Island Open Website Open GBP 34 4.4 ★ 1 0 0% 2 6
FUN Rentals LLC, F & R Tent's & Party Rentals Open Website Open GBP 80 4.8 ★ 6 23 34.8% 0 0
Patanjo's Load-N-Go Open Website Open GBP 13 4.4 ★ 4 24 0.0% 0 0

🔓 Learn More at LPRAudit.com

Get the data for your company with the Full LPRAudit.com Report and tools, the Website Guru Report, or the basic Comparing your services on your Google Business with your Website only in our Quick Snapshot report.

Learn More →